Deep plane and traditional facelifts both target ageing in the lower face and neck. Where they part company is depth. One works closer to the surface, the other goes beneath it, and that changes the look of the result, how long it holds, and what your recovery will be like. Plenty of people arrive at a consultation having read about the deep plane technique and wanting to know one thing: is it really a different operation, or just a newer label on an old one? Here is where the two genuinely differ.
Asking which technique is “best” in the abstract does not get you far. The question that matters is which one suits your face. Your anatomy, how far the ageing has progressed, and what you actually want to change all feed into the answer. It is a judgement a Specialist Plastic Surgeon makes with you in the room, not something to choose off a trend list.
A quick word on why facial ageing happens (and why lifts work)
Skin gets the blame. It does loosen, but it is hardly working alone up there. Underneath, the deeper support tissues drift down over the years, and the fat pads that give a cheek its fullness lose volume and slip towards the jaw. So by the time you notice anything, three separate things have been going on for a while. The mirror only shows you the total. A softer jawline. Folds cutting deeper from nose to mouth. Definition that has quietly gone somewhere. Mid-forties is the usual moment it registers.
Under the skin and fat there is a layer with an unwieldy name: the superficial musculoaponeurotic system, or SMAS for short. Think of it as the sheet of tissue and muscle that keeps a face in shape. Nearly every modern facelift does something with it. Why bother? Because pulling on skin alone looks pulled, and it does not hold. What separates a traditional lift from a deep plane lift is simply what each one does with that layer.
What is a traditional (SMAS) facelift?
A traditional facelift, usually called a SMAS facelift, tightens and repositions that SMAS layer, then trims the excess skin sitting over it. The skin is lifted first. The SMAS is then treated on its own, by folding, trimming or suturing it into a firmer position, and the skin is re-draped over the new contour. Incisions sit within the hairline and around the ears, so scarring settles into creases that are already there.
Decades of use sit behind this one. Jowling usually improves. The jawline generally comes back cleaner. Recovery usually asks a little less of you than the deeper techniques do. Its limit is the midface: skin and SMAS get handled as separate layers, so heavier midface descent, and those deeper folds beside the nose and mouth, may not shift as much as you would hope. Pull harder on the skin to make up the difference and you get the tight, “operated” look that gives facelifts a bad name. Steering around that is most of the craft.
What is a deep plane facelift?
A deep plane facelift goes a layer further down. Instead of lifting skin off the SMAS, the surgeon works underneath the SMAS and releases the facial retaining ligaments, which are the small fibrous anchors tethering ageing tissue in place. Free those, and skin, fat and muscle can be moved together as a single unit rather than in pieces. The direction of the lift is more vertical too.
So why bother going deeper? Because the tissue that dropped is the tissue worth moving. Stretch the surface and you have only disguised the drop. Surgeons working in this plane usually describe faces that still move like faces. They report better correction through the midface and around the mouth. They report results that hang on longer too, though longer is not the same as permanent, and nothing stops ageing. The catch falls on the surgeon rather than on you. This dissection runs close to branches of the facial nerve. Training and theatre hours count for a great deal here.
Deep plane vs SMAS: a side-by-side comparison
The table sets the two out side by side. Treat it as a rough map of how the techniques differ. It is not a rule about your face, because no table knows your face.
| Traditional (SMAS) facelift | Deep plane facelift | |
|---|---|---|
| Tissue depth | Skin and SMAS handled as separate layers | Dissection beneath the SMAS, releasing the retaining ligaments |
| Areas best improved | Jowls and jawline | Jowls, jawline, midface and the folds beside the nose and mouth |
| Naturalness of movement | Natural when skin tension is kept modest | Tends to preserve natural movement, as the tissues move together |
| Longevity (general, not a guarantee) | Commonly described in the range of several years | Often described as longer-lasting |
| Recovery window (general) | Swelling and bruising mostly settling over roughly two to three weeks | Broadly similar, though the deeper work can mean more early swelling |
| Often suits | Earlier or moderate ageing | More advanced midface descent, deeper folds, heavier tissue |
Be wary of the longevity numbers you see quoted online. Neither technique stops ageing. How long a result holds comes down to your tissue and skin quality, your genetics, and how well you look after your skin afterwards. Published figures are averages drawn from a lot of different people. They are not a prediction of what will happen to your face.
Which technique is right for you?
No single answer covers everyone. Broadly speaking, a deep plane facelift tends to come into the conversation when midface descent is more advanced, the nasolabial folds are deeper, or the tissue is simply heavier, because it goes after that deeper drop directly. Where jowls and the jawline are the main concern and the ageing is earlier or moderate, a SMAS facelift can serve you well. Which one fits your face is not something an article can settle. It takes an in-person assessment, where your surgeon can examine your tissue and be specific about what each approach would and would not change.
The neck tends to age alongside the lower face, which is why a neck lift is frequently combined with a facelift. Dr David Sparks performs deep plane neck lift, so the neck can sit inside the same plan where that is appropriate. Some patients add surgery around the eyes as well, such as blepharoplasty, where the eyelids are part of the picture. Whether combining makes sense for you is a decision to reach with your surgeon, weighing the benefit against one longer recovery.
What does deep plane facelift recovery look like?
Recovery takes its time, and it goes better when you plan for it instead of trying to rush it. Swelling and bruising are expected through the first one to two weeks, and most people would rather not be seen during that stretch. Social downtime commonly runs to two or three weeks, though that varies a fair bit. Tightness and firmness in the treated areas can hang around, and tissues keep settling for months afterwards. The early days are not when you judge the result.
Some practical things do help. Keeping your head elevated, including overnight, eases early swelling. Holding off on strenuous activity and heavy lifting until you are cleared gives tissue the time it needs. Turn up to your follow-up appointments as well, because that is where your surgeon checks how you are healing and answers the questions that surface along the way. Recovery is individual, and you will be given post-operative instructions written for your procedure.
Risks and important considerations
Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks, and a facelift is no exception. The general surgical risks include bleeding, infection, delayed healing, scarring and reactions to anaesthesia. Numbness or altered sensation in the skin is common while nerves recover, and it usually settles. Because a deep plane facelift involves dissection close to branches of the facial nerve, there is also a risk of weakness affecting facial movement. That is usually temporary, though uncommonly it lasts longer. Asymmetry is possible. So is a result that does not fully match what you had pictured, and in some cases a further procedure may be considered later.
This is not a decision to rush. Seek a second opinion if that helps you feel confident about it. Talk to your GP about your general health. And check that whoever performs your surgery is a Specialist Plastic Surgeon registered with AHPRA. Results vary between individuals. A thorough consultation is where the risks relevant to your situation get explained in full, before you commit to anything.
Why choose Vie Plastic Surgery for a facelift on the Sunshine Coast
Facelift surgery here is carried out by Dr David Sparks, a Specialist Plastic Surgeon and a Fellow of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (FRACS), with the qualifications MBBS (Hons), MS (Plast), PhD and FRACS (Plast). That specialist registration matters, and it is worth knowing why. It is not the same thing as the title “cosmetic surgeon”. We encourage every patient to look their surgeon up on the AHPRA register and check for themselves.
Dr Sparks has more than a decade of surgical experience behind him and a particular interest in deep plane face and neck lift. His training took him through major public and private hospitals in Queensland and New South Wales, with further time interstate and overseas refining his facial surgery work. He also performs blepharoplasty, brow rejuvenation, lip lift and otoplasty, so a plan can be built around your face rather than fitted to one procedure.
Established in 1994, Vie Plastic Surgery and Cosmetic Clinic in Maroochydore is one of the longest-standing plastic surgical practices on the Sunshine Coast. A consultation is your chance to have your face assessed and to ask whatever you need to ask. You will get honest information about which technique may suit you, what the recovery actually involves, and the realistic range of outcomes. All of that comes before you decide anything. To arrange a consultation with Dr Sparks, phone the clinic on (07) 5438 3588.
Frequently asked questions
Is a deep plane facelift better than a SMAS facelift?
Neither, as a blanket rule. Different faces, different answers. A deep plane lift is built for deeper midface descent and heavier folds, since it shifts tissue as one unit. Where jowls and the jawline are the main story, a SMAS lift can be the better fit. Your anatomy and your goals settle it, and both want looking at in person.
How long does a deep plane facelift last?
There is no fixed figure, and no facelift stops ageing. Because deeper tissues are repositioned, results are often described as holding longer than a SMAS lift, but that still depends on your skin, your genetics, your lifestyle and how much sun you get. Your surgeon can give you a realistic sense of what to expect.
How long is recovery after a deep plane facelift?
It is gradual. Swelling and bruising are expected across the first one to two weeks, and social downtime is commonly two to three weeks. Tissues carry on settling for months afterwards, so the final result takes a while to show itself. This varies from person to person.
Is a deep plane facelift more risky?
It is more technically demanding, yes, because the dissection sits close to facial nerve branches. Hence the emphasis on who is holding the instruments. Risk comes with all surgery: bleeding, infection, scarring, altered sensation, and, with the deeper techniques, temporary facial nerve weakness. Your surgeon will go through the ones relevant to you at your consultation.
Can a deep plane facelift be combined with a neck lift or eyelid surgery?
Yes, and it is common. The neck ages alongside the lower face, so a neck lift is often combined with it, and eyelid surgery (blepharoplasty) may be added where the eyes are part of the concern. Combining means one recovery period rather than two, which your surgeon will talk through at the planning stage.
Further reading
- What Is Facelift Surgery?: a plain-English overview of what a facelift does, and what it does not.
- Facelift (Rhytidectomy): the facelift service page, including the options available at Vie.
- Neck Lift: how a neck lift works, and when it is combined with a facelift.
- Blepharoplasty (Eyelid Surgery): a common companion procedure for the upper and lower eyelids.
Medical references
- Healthdirect Australia, Facelift: https://www.healthdirect.gov.au/facelift/
- Australian Society of Plastic Surgeons, Facelift surgery: https://plasticsurgery.org.au/procedures/surgical-procedures/facelift-surgery/
- Better Health Channel (Victorian Government), Facelift (meloplasty): https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/conditionsandtreatments/facelift-meloplasty/
- Cleveland Clinic, Facelift (Rhytidectomy): https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/treatments/23530-facelift-rhytidectomy/
- Medical Board of Australia, Guidelines for medical practitioners who advertise cosmetic surgery: https://www.medicalboard.gov.au/Codes-Guidelines-Policies/Guidelines-for-registered-medical-practitioners-who-advertise-cosmetic-surgery.aspx/
This article is general information only and is not a substitute for individual medical advice. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding with any procedure, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.
Call Now
Contact Us
Chat Now